Skip to main content

Time Delay (TD)

A practice used to systematically fade the use of prompts during instructional activities by using a brief delay between the initial instruction and any additional instructions or prompts.

Evidence Based
Ages: Skip to Evidence

Steps for Implementation

Step 1. Identifying Target Skill/Behavior(s)

  1. Define the target skill/behavior in terms that are observable and measurable.
  2. Identify the target skill/behavior as being either:
    1. a discrete task or
    2. a chained task
  3. Define learner response behaviors.

Step 2. Determining Current Skills

  1. Assess a learner’s current skills by directly observing the learner during daily routines and activities.
  2. Determine a learner’s current ability to:
    1. respond to instructional cues,
    2. wait,
    3. imitate others,
    4. stay seated during individual or small group work time,
    5. increase positive behaviors in response to reinforcers, and
    6. follow one-step instructions.

Step 3. Selecting the Target Stimulus and Cue/Task Direction

  1. Identify one of the following as the target stimulus:
    1. a naturally occurring event,
    2. completion of one event or activity, or
    3. an external signal
  2. Select at least one of the following cues to begin the teaching activity:
    1. material or environmental manipulation,
    2. task direction, or
    3. naturally occurring event.

Step 4. Selecting the Controlling Prompt

Try different prompts to identify ones that successfully elicit the desired response.

Step 5. Identifying Reinforcers

  1. When choosing reinforcers for a learner with autism, identify:
    1. what has motivated the learner in the past and
    2. the learner’s deprivation state.
  2. Identify a reinforcer that is appropriate for the target skill/behavior and instructional task.

Step 6. Determining the Response Interval

When determining the length of the response interval, consider:

  • learner characteristics and
  • task characteristics.

Step 7. Identifying Activities and Times for Teaching

  1. Identify one regular time during the day when the target skill/behavior can be taught and measured.
  2. Identify how many trials will be implemented during instructional activities.

Step 8. Establishing Learner Attention, Delivering the Stimulus, and Providing the Cue

Gain the learner’s attention by:

  1. delivering the target stimulus,
  2. using an attention-getting strategy, and
  3. presenting the cue or task direction.

Step 9. Implementing the Time Delay

  1. After securing the learner’s attention, presenting the target stimulus, and delivering the cue/task direction, immediately deliver the controlling prompt.
  2. If the learner’s response is correct, immediately provide positive feedback by:
    1. offering reinforcement (e.g., praise, access to materials, break) and
    2. stating what the learner did (“You said, ‘More.’ Here’s more snack.”).
  3. If the learner’s response is incorrect or if the learner does not respond, ignore the response and go on to the next trial.

Step 10. Increasing the Delay

(With this step, use either constant or progressive time delay. Once a time delay procedure has been chosen, follow the appropriate steps for implementing that procedure).

Constant Time Delay

  1. Present the cue to the learner.
  2. Wait 3 to 5 seconds for the learner to use the target skill/behavior.
  3. If the learner’s response is correct, immediately provide positive feedback by:
    1. offering reinforcement (e.g., praise, access to materials, break) and
    2. stating what the learner did (e.g., “You said, ‘More.’ Here’s more snack.” “You said, ‘Two times two is four.’ That’s right. Two times two is four.”).
  4. If the learner’s response is incorrect, ignore the response and go on to the next trial.
  5. If the learner does not respond during the response interval:
    1. deliver the controlling prompt and
    2. insert the response interval.
  6. If the learner responds correctly after the prompt (prompted correct), immediately provide reinforcement.
  7. If the learner responds incorrectly after the prompt (prompted error), ignore the response and go on to the next trial.
  8. If the learner does not respond after the prompt (no response), ignore the learner and go on to the next trial.

Progressive Time Delay

  1. Present the cue to the learner.
  2. Wait, using the increased delay time, before prompting the learner to use the skill.
  3. If the learner’s response is correct, immediately provide positive feedback by:
    1. offering reinforcement (e.g., praise, access to materials, break) and
    2. stating what the learner did (e.g., “You said, ‘More.’ Here’s more snack.” “You said, ‘Two times two is four.’ That’s right. Two times two is four.”).
  4. If the learner’s response is incorrect, ignore the response and go onto the next trial.
  5. If the learner does not respond during the response interval:
    1. deliver the controlling prompt and
    2. insert another response interval.
  6. If the learner responds correctly after the prompt (prompted correct), immediately provide reinforcement.
  7. If the learner responds incorrectly after the prompt (prompted error), ignore the response and go on to the next trial.
  8. If the learner does not respond after the prompt (no response), ignore the learner and go on to the next trial.

Step 11. Monitoring Progress

  1. Record the number of correct/incorrect learner responses during the teaching activity.
  2. Review progress monitoring data after two teaching activities to determine the learner’s mastery of the target skill/behavior.
  3. Gradually increase the time delay (e.g., by 1-second intervals) as learners demonstrate 100% mastery of the target skill/behavior during the previous activity.

Research and Outcomes

Research Summary

Age Range: 0-22

Skills: Communication, social, joint attention, play, cognitive, school readiness, academic/pre-academic, adaptive/self-help, challenging/interfering behavior, vocational, motor

Settings: Home, school, community, clinic

Evidence Rating: Evidence Based

The information found in the Research Summary table is updated following a literature review of new research and these ages, skills, and settings reflects information from this review.

Outcomes Matrix

The Outcomes Matrix shows outcome areas by age for which this evidence based practice is effective
Age: 0-5 6-14 15-22
Academic/Pre-academic Yes Yes Yes
Challenging/Interfering Behavior Yes Yes
Cognitive Yes Yes
Communication Yes Yes Yes
Joint Attention Yes Yes
Mental Health
Motor Yes
Play Yes Yes
School Readiness Yes Yes Yes
Self-determination
Social Yes Yes
Vocational Yes Yes
More about Intervention Outcomes

Time delay (TD) is a practice used to systematically fade the use of prompts during instructional activities. With this procedure, a brief delay is provided between the initial instruction and any additional instructions or prompts. The evidence-based research focuses on two types of time delay procedures: progressive and constant. With progressive time delay, the practitioner gradually increases the waiting time between an instruction and any prompts that might be used to elicit a response from a learner. As the learner becomes more proficient at using the skill, the practitioner gradually increases the waiting time between the instruction and the prompt. In constant time delay, a fixed amount of time is always used between the instruction and the prompt as the learner becomes more proficient at using the new skill. Time delay is always used in conjunction with a prompting procedure (e.g., least-to-most prompting, simultaneous prompting, graduated guidance) (Steinbrenner, et al., 2020).